32
responses
Share Article:
Australia (Reviews)

Australia (Reviews)

By
Dec 3, 2008
Our Rating:
Your Rating:
click to rate!
VN:F [1.9.12_1141]
3.2/5
(9 votes)
Australia (Reviews), reviewed by Anders Wotzke on 2008-12-03T17:17:52+00:00 rating 3.5 out of5

Review by Katina.

AUSTRALIA has the weight of the world on its shoulders as the pre-Oscar buzz surrounding it includes approval from Oprah, the biggest budget for a feature film in Australian history, and the knowledge that Nicole Kidman’s previous few offerings have been box office disasters. With Baz Lurhmann returning to feature filmmaking after 2001’s Moulin Rouge! and his known influences of the golden age, this sweeping romantic epic said to be Australia’s answer to Gone with the Wind has a lot to answer for. The modern masterpiece it’s being made out to be may just be that – made out. On the other hand, there’s a different opinion for those wanting a good, old-fashioned film.

Originally slated in the male lead, Russell Crowe pulled out of production due to scheduling issues before Hugh Jackman provided the replacement. Production on AUSTRALIA lasted for 2 years – 4 years before that on working out scripts, characters and locations, while Lurhmann put finishing touches the night before last month’s world premiere. He is known for paying attention to detail and prides himself on giving the viewer a visual experience. That certainly works to his favour in this film – the stunning Australian Outback is served beautifully with the help of cinematographer Mandy Walker, best known for her work in 2001’s Lantana. Dramatic sweeping aerial shots make you ashamed of not having explored what’s in our own backyard. No doubt this film is marketed to overseas audiences, particularly the USA with Oscar aspirations – and sometimes it gives the impression of a tourism ad. That’s not a coincidence, with Lurhmann producing an ad for Tourism Australia in conjunction with the film.

Written by Lurhmann and long-time collaborator Stuart Beattie, the theatric feel continues as a main theme in any Bazmark production. Using inspiration from films like Oklahoma and The Wizard of Oz (directly used in quite a sweet way), Lurhmann gives us a surprisingly funny beginning as we watch Lady Sarah Ashley (Nicole Kidman) settle into her husband’s Faraway Downs estate with The Drover (Hugh Jackman, cementing a desire to see more romantic leads from him in the future). Kidman is enjoyably funny, and turns to more dramatic circumstances with relative ease. The real stars are in the support, with David Wenham as the chauvinistic villain Neil Fletcher, and young Brandon Walters as Nullah. After an extensive 2000-auditionee search, his innocence plays perfectly into Lurhmann’s hands in providing theatrical magic and could well earn him an Oscar nomination. The Indigenous involvement in this film is more than what has been portrayed and it’s surprising to see such talent within a very important story. Lurhmann uses this opportunity to create a portrayal of The Stolen Generation, something that many Australians don’t have a good understanding of. While it is a version suitable for a Hollywood film, nevertheless the WWII backdrop serves as a reminder of the closest Australia has been directly affected by war.

At almost three hours, it does deliver as an epic in the vein of his inspiration, but Lurhmann obviously had different ideas of how he wanted his film to look, as witnessed by those in the first test screenings. Unlike so many character-driven films lately, AUSTRALIA has a real story behind it, moving along at a good pace as we see if Lady Sarah can outstay the baddies and conquer with love on her side. The characters are all likeable (and Fletcher excellently hatable), but it could have benefited from an extended cut to draw out the growing love between Lady Sarah and The Drover. It contains everything an epic should – romance, drama, action, and in this case, comedy, but it isn’t the absolute masterpiece we were hoping for. However, for its extravagance it’s still a very good film and it did come close, clearly showing the comfort Kidman has with Lurhmann, and providing a good reason for Americans and the like to visit our land. After all, how can Americans say no to seeing a kangaroo? Even if they do realize when they’re here it’s more likely to be in a zoo?

 

Follow the author Anders Wotzke on Twitter.

  • elise

    Very nice! I don’t think the review is too long (but I like reading) – an ‘epic’ movie deserves an epic review, right?! Totally agree that it was an enjoyable three hours of cinema, and I left with a smile, but not saying, ‘Crikey, that was unbelievable!!’ hahaha :)

    Maybe if you do think it’s too long, have a condensed version, and then people can read this one if they want a more in-depth review. I think you should leave it the way it is though, I enjoyed the read!

    Keep up the good work!!

  • elise

    Very nice! I don’t think the review is too long (but I like reading) – an ‘epic’ movie deserves an epic review, right?! Totally agree that it was an enjoyable three hours of cinema, and I left with a smile, but not saying, ‘Crikey, that was unbelievable!!’ hahaha :)

    Maybe if you do think it’s too long, have a condensed version, and then people can read this one if they want a more in-depth review. I think you should leave it the way it is though, I enjoyed the read!

    Keep up the good work!!

  • Mike

    Nice review. The screen shots you have show off that blue screen look we were talking about, ah well still enjoyed it.

  • Mike

    Nice review. The screen shots you have show off that blue screen look we were talking about, ah well still enjoyed it.

  • http://cutprintreview.com Anders

    @elise
    Thanks for the comment Elise!
    You’re right, when a film is 3 hours long, one would expect to see a long review.
    I might do a smaller version, although i guess if people want they can just skip down to the Conclusion.

    What i really need to do is proof read it first….i just did so then and spotted so many little errors. Wish i had an editor!

  • http://cutprintreview.com Anders

    @elise
    Thanks for the comment Elise!
    You’re right, when a film is 3 hours long, one would expect to see a long review.
    I might do a smaller version, although i guess if people want they can just skip down to the Conclusion.

    What i really need to do is proof read it first….i just did so then and spotted so many little errors. Wish i had an editor!

  • http://cutprintreview.com Anders

    @Mike – If that shot is anything to go by, I think it was a completely deliberate look. I like it to. Dreamlike. On the big screen, it’s hard to tell though. I would like to watch this on blu-ray.

  • http://cutprintreview.com Anders

    @Mike – If that shot is anything to go by, I think it was a completely deliberate look. I like it to. Dreamlike. On the big screen, it’s hard to tell though. I would like to watch this on blu-ray.

  • elise

    @Anders – If you’d like an editor, I could help out – I am a spelling, grammar and formatting nazi!!

  • elise

    @Anders – If you’d like an editor, I could help out – I am a spelling, grammar and formatting nazi!!

  • Anonymous

    a very solid review anders, despite me feeling it was maybe overly harsh in some area. i enjoyed the fact that every characters story wasnt spoon fed to the audience, as it allows for the audience to form their own opinions of the characters.

    i do agree though, Australia was not what we needed it be be, despite it being a good movie

  • Anonymous

    a very solid review anders, despite me feeling it was maybe overly harsh in some area. i enjoyed the fact that every characters story wasnt spoon fed to the audience, as it allows for the audience to form their own opinions of the characters.

    i do agree though, Australia was not what we needed it be be, despite it being a good movie

  • http://cutprintreview.com Anders

    Originally Posted By elise@Anders – If you’d like an editor, I could help out – I am a spelling, grammar and formatting nazi!!

    Ooh thanks for the offer Elise! Sign up to the site, and i’ll have a look see to see if it’s possible to allow you to edit my posts and what not.

  • http://cutprintreview.com Anders

    Originally Posted By elise
    @Anders – If you’d like an editor, I could help out – I am a spelling, grammar and formatting nazi!!

    Ooh thanks for the offer Elise! Sign up to the site, and i’ll have a look see to see if it’s possible to allow you to edit my posts and what not.

  • http://cutprintreview.com Anders

    @Anonymous
    Thanks for the comment! Good point, however I guess it’s my personal preference to be presented characters a bit more fleshed out than what they were here. For example, it was a bit put off by the fact that the film never really showed Lady Ashley grieve over her dead husband…we ended up knowing nothing about him or their relationship (even if it wasn’t strong, we didn’t really know). It just sorta blew out the window 10 minutes in.

  • http://cutprintreview.com Anders

    @Anonymous
    Thanks for the comment! Good point, however I guess it’s my personal preference to be presented characters a bit more fleshed out than what they were here. For example, it was a bit put off by the fact that the film never really showed Lady Ashley grieve over her dead husband…we ended up knowing nothing about him or their relationship (even if it wasn’t strong, we didn’t really know). It just sorta blew out the window 10 minutes in.

  • Anonymous

    Good review :)
    I completely agree with what you said. Baz set himself an enormous challenge, and pulled it off reasonably well…although, I must admit that I left the cinema feeling a little underwhelmed. The characters were quite underdeveloped which was disappointing, and Luhrmann clearly overreached with the many subplots he tried to shove the film (which could have quite easily been spilt up into two films). Like you said Anders, individually the different plot lines were fantastic, but the problem was that he spread each of them to thin, and didn’t really delve into any of them. The true magic of Australia was most definitely in its cinematography! Luhrmann’s distinct theatrical style was evident in more than a few scenes, but it was great to see that he avoided utilising his trademark dramatic and exaggerated style of directing (as it’s clearly not well suited to this kind of movie), and this undoubtedly did the film justice. I’d agree with your 3 ½ star rating!
    kudos on the review!

  • Anonymous

    Good review :)
    I completely agree with what you said. Baz set himself an enormous challenge, and pulled it off reasonably well…although, I must admit that I left the cinema feeling a little underwhelmed. The characters were quite underdeveloped which was disappointing, and Luhrmann clearly overreached with the many subplots he tried to shove the film (which could have quite easily been spilt up into two films). Like you said Anders, individually the different plot lines were fantastic, but the problem was that he spread each of them to thin, and didn’t really delve into any of them. The true magic of Australia was most definitely in its cinematography! Luhrmann’s distinct theatrical style was evident in more than a few scenes, but it was great to see that he avoided utilising his trademark dramatic and exaggerated style of directing (as it’s clearly not well suited to this kind of movie), and this undoubtedly did the film justice. I’d agree with your 3 ½ star rating!
    kudos on the review!

  • Ana

    it is a little long there anders, but it’s well written and you back up your arguments well.

    hai!! i didnt know you had a site for movie reviews :)

  • Ana

    it is a little long there anders, but it’s well written and you back up your arguments well.

    hai!! i didnt know you had a site for movie reviews :)

  • Graeme Walker

    Being the father of Mandy Walker, the Cinematographer of “Australia” I have received tremendous response from many of my friends who have seen the film. They enjoyed the story, the impact of “Nulla” and of course the cinematography. Baz Luhrmann is a unique story teller – the film is NOT a documentary, as many critics have outlined saying certain facts about the Australian history is wrong – ie., the invasion of Mission Island by the Japanese. The film is entertaining, visual and with an all Australian cast and crew. What more does the Australian public want – as Baz Luhrmann said – the public will vote with their feet !!

  • http://Nil Graeme Walker

    Being the father of Mandy Walker, the Cinematographer of “Australia” I have received tremendous response from many of my friends who have seen the film. They enjoyed the story, the impact of “Nulla” and of course the cinematography. Baz Luhrmann is a unique story teller – the film is NOT a documentary, as many critics have outlined saying certain facts about the Australian history is wrong – ie., the invasion of Mission Island by the Japanese. The film is entertaining, visual and with an all Australian cast and crew. What more does the Australian public want – as Baz Luhrmann said – the public will vote with their feet !!

  • http://cutprintreview.com/about-us/profiles/ Anders

    Thank you for leave a comment Graeme!
    Certainly, a director deserves his creative license…especially Luhrmann.
    I would be surprised if anyone who knew Luhrmann’s earlier works and still walked into Australia expecting a documentary style of film…it was certainly a epic ‘story’ in every sense of the word and never disguised itself as otherwise.

    Also, best of luck to your daughter in the upcoming awards season, not that she’ll need it! I’ll be quite astonished if she’s not given an Oscar nomination. Her work on the film was truly something special and I look forward to seeing her work in the future.

  • http://cutprintreview.com/about-us/profiles/ Anders

    Thank you for leave a comment Graeme!
    Certainly, a director deserves his creative license…especially Luhrmann.
    I would be surprised if anyone who knew Luhrmann’s earlier works and still walked into Australia expecting a documentary style of film…it was certainly a epic ‘story’ in every sense of the word and never disguised itself as otherwise.

    Also, best of luck to your daughter in the upcoming awards season, not that she’ll need it! I’ll be quite astonished if she’s not given an Oscar nomination. Her work on the film was truly something special and I look forward to seeing her work in the future.

  • letesha C

    I agree with Baz, ‘Australia’ was for me a great ‘Sunday Roast’ not a bland takeaway on TV tray. I felt very satisfied with the overall offering. As with any good roast you must have the meat but without all the vegetables it would be pretty dull. I had to laugh at the spaghetti western feel of some of the characters and then I felt angry when our old sores of child stealing were opened. The gravy that kept it all flowing was the cinematography. I left the cinema thinking we now had the Australian equivalent of ‘Gone with the wind”

  • letesha C

    I agree with Baz, ‘Australia’ was for me a great ‘Sunday Roast’ not a bland takeaway on TV tray. I felt very satisfied with the overall offering. As with any good roast you must have the meat but without all the vegetables it would be pretty dull. I had to laugh at the spaghetti western feel of some of the characters and then I felt angry when our old sores of child stealing were opened. The gravy that kept it all flowing was the cinematography. I left the cinema thinking we now had the Australian equivalent of ‘Gone with the wind”

  • http://mp3sstore.org/xbox-p-51/ Music_Mp3_Earnepevate

    Hello to all :) I can’t understand how to add your site in my rss reader. Help me, please

  • http://mp3sstore.org/xbox-p-51/ Music_Mp3_Earnepevate

    Hello to all :) I can’t understand how to add your site in my rss reader. Help me, please

  • Pingback: Rabbit Hole (Review) | Cut Print Review

  • Pingback: textile reports

  • Pingback: garment sales worldwide

  • Pingback: hot news